Research
The cases and the official record
Each published Kettei case rests on a public record. This page lists the record behind each case, what it found, and the failure mode Kettei reads in it.
The cases are examples and the failure mode is the subject. Each was chosen because an inquiry, a regulator, a court or the organisation's own filings put the facts on the public record. The middle column of the table reports that record. The last column is Kettei's reading, which the authors of the record did not make.
Several essays state a limit on the reading, and the limit belongs with the case. On Challenger, the essay says no record can show that a boundary would have stopped the launch. Whether a trigger would have changed Carillion's accounts is, by that essay's account, beyond what the record can settle. The Post Office judgments, as the essay notes, make no finding about motive.
The record behind each case
| Case | What the source found | How Kettei reads it |
|---|---|---|
| Boeing 737 MAX | According to the final report of the US House Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure, a 2016 change gave the flight-control software more authority to move the horizontal stabiliser at low speed, so that the aircraft could meet stall requirements needed for certification. | The founding classification of the aircraft as a derivative was a decision whose assumptions were not written down as conditions that would send it back for review. |
| Ajax | The National Audit Office reported that the senior responsible owner "was initially allocated to the programme for 10% of his time". The Sheldon review found concerns "were discussed and decided within the DE&S chain of command without input from the SRO". | Decision vacancy. A name in the owner's box did not amount to a person holding the decision's continuing validity. |
| Novopay | The Ministerial Inquiry found that "The actual Go Live decision was made on 31 May 2012", and that abandoning the phased rollout and the pilot "increased the project's dependency on testing". | Coupling blindness. The pilot decision and the testing programme were coupled, and the coupling went undeclared. |
| Knight Capital | The Securities and Exchange Commission's order found the firm "did not have procedures in place to halt SMARS's operations in response to its own aberrant activity." | Ungoverned persistence. No condition for switching the router off had been written in advance. |
| NHS National Programme for IT | The Public Accounts Committee found that after the 2011 announcement "the component programmes are all continuing, the existing contracts are being honoured and significant costs are still being incurred." | Ungoverned persistence. The point at which each commitment was decided again was an expiry date set when the contracts were let. |
| Peloton | The company's filings record a factory announced in May 2021, a forecast cut in November 2021 that named "a more pronounced tapering of demand", and the development wound down in February 2022. | Assumption drift. The premise of growth was written without a level below which the commitment came back for review. |
| Equifax | The House Oversight Committee's majority staff report found a device that "had been inactive for 19 months due to an expired security certificate", and "a lack of accountability and no clear lines of authority". | Trigger register decay, with decision vacancy underneath it. |
| Challenger | The Rogers Commission found that as flights confirmed damage to the seals, the reaction "was to increase the amount of damage considered 'acceptable.'" | Normalisation of deviance. A threshold fixed in advance gives later reviews a reference that a single flight does not move. |
| Columbia | The Columbia Accident Investigation Board found that the changes made after Challenger "were undone over time by management actions". | Reflection theatre. A lesson counts when it is installed as a mechanism. |
| Taurus | The Chancellor told the Commons on 16 March 1993 that stamp duty on shares, due to go once Taurus was running, would stay. Press reports of the day put the City's losses at £275 million or more. | Escalation of commitment. The accounts cited record no condition, set at the start, under which the project would end. |
| Carillion | The joint select committee report said of the company's checks and balances that "These all failed", and recorded a peer review that put a contract at a loss while the accounts booked a profit. | Governance theatre. The output of a control could be set aside before it reached a decision. |
| Mid Staffordshire | The Francis inquiry named among the causes an assumption that monitoring, performance management or intervention was "the responsibility of someone else". | Signals ignored. A trigger fires and the owner does not act. |
| Piper Alpha | Lord Cullen found that staff learned the permit to work system by watching others, a method he said suffers from "perpetuating or accumulating errors". | Documentation-reality divergence. The written procedure and the practised one had separated. |
| The Post Office and Horizon | In the Horizon Issues judgment of 16 December 2019 the judge observed that one word "has been at the heart of the Post Office's defence of the Horizon system for many years". | Institutional moralisation. The reading is Kettei's, and the judgments make no finding about motive. |
| Silicon Valley Bank | The Federal Reserve's review of its own supervision noted that "the vacancy in a post like CRO removes one layer of important internal oversight." | Supervisors flagged the risk, and the flag did not become a revalidation of the decision. |
| Queensland Health payroll | The Commission of Inquiry placed the replacement "in the front rank of failures in public administration in this country". | Several modes in one record. On Kettei's reading, normalisation of deviance prepared the ground for governance theatre. |
| Prevention of Terrorism Act 1974 | Section 12 of the Act let its powers lapse unless an order continued the powers, for no more than 6 months at a time. The temporary powers stayed in force for a little over 26 years. | Authority capture. The section set an expiry and no condition for ending the powers. |
Sources
- US House Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure (2020) Final Committee Report: The Design, Development and Certification of the Boeing 737 MAX. September 2020.
- Joint Authorities Technical Review (2019) Boeing 737 MAX Flight Control System: Observations, Findings, and Recommendations. Submitted to the FAA, 11 October 2019.
- KNKT (2019) Final report, PK-LQP. The accident investigation report for Lion Air Flight 610.
- National Audit Office (2022) The Ajax programme. Report by the Comptroller and Auditor General, HC 1142, Session 2021-22, 11 March 2022.
- Sheldon, C. (2023) Report of the Armoured Cavalry Programme (Ajax) Lessons Learned Review. Ministry of Defence, 19 May 2023.
- Ministerial Inquiry into the Novopay Project (Jack, M. and Wevers, M.) (2013) Report of the Ministerial Inquiry into the Novopay Project. Wellington, June 2013.
- US Securities and Exchange Commission (2013) In the Matter of Knight Capital Americas LLC. Release No. 34-70694, 16 October 2013.
- House of Commons Committee of Public Accounts (2013) The dismantled National Programme for IT in the NHS. Nineteenth Report of Session 2013-14, HC 294, published 18 September 2013.
- Peloton Interactive, Inc. (2021) Peloton to Build First U.S. Factory, press release, 24 May 2021; Q1 2022 Shareholder Letter, 4 November 2021; and (2022) Peloton Announces Comprehensive Program to Reduce Costs and Drive Growth, Profitability, and Free Cash Flow, press release, 8 February 2022.
- US House of Representatives, Committee on Oversight and Government Reform (2018) The Equifax Data Breach. Majority Staff Report, 115th Congress, December 2018.
- Presidential Commission on the Space Shuttle Challenger Accident (Rogers, W. P., Chairman) (1986) Report of the Presidential Commission on the Space Shuttle Challenger Accident, Volume 1.
- Columbia Accident Investigation Board (2003) Report Volume I. August 2003. Washington DC: Government Printing Office.
- House of Commons (1993) Budget Statement, section "TAURUS". HC Deb 16 March 1993 vol 221 c178.
- House of Commons Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy and Work and Pensions Committees (2018) Carillion. Second Joint report of Session 2017-19, HC 769, published 16 May 2018.
- Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust Public Inquiry (Francis, R., QC, Chairman) (2013) Report of the Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust Public Inquiry: Executive Summary. HC 947, February 2013.
- Cullen, The Hon Lord (1990) The Public Inquiry into the Piper Alpha Disaster, Volume One. Department of Energy, Cm 1310, November 1990.
- High Court of Justice, Queen's Bench Division (Fraser J) (2019) Bates and Others v Post Office Ltd, Judgment (No.6) "Horizon Issues", [2019] EWHC 3408 (QB), 16 December 2019; and Judgment (No.3) "Common Issues", [2019] EWHC 606 (QB), 15 March 2019.
- Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2023) Review of the Federal Reserve's Supervision and Regulation of Silicon Valley Bank. 28 April 2023.
- Queensland Health Payroll System Commission of Inquiry (Chesterman, R. N., Commissioner) (2013) Queensland Health Payroll System Commission of Inquiry Report. Queensland, 31 July 2013.
- Prevention of Terrorism (Temporary Provisions) Act 1974 (c. 56), section 12; and House of Commons (1974) Terrorism: statement by the Home Secretary. HC Deb 25 November 1974 vol 882 cc33-45.
More cases
A further set of cases is gathered in Boeing Is Only One Example, a free handout of 29 cases. The Boeing case is set out in full at The Decision That Could Not Expire, with The Decision Reached the Cockpit Last and The Silent Decision beside it.

Kettei
The Discipline of Governed Intent
