Learn
Kettei Learn
Each page here answers one question about governing a decision after it is approved. The pages are drawn from essays already published free on Kettei on Substack, and each links to its original.
Kettei is when intent is held outside a single skull. Once a consequential decision is approved, the programme and its budget each keep an owner, and whether the decision behind both still holds is rarely anyone's explicit job. The pages below set out the terms Kettei uses for that job, one term to a page.
Decision governance
- Which decisions deserve governance? Kettei governs the decisions that steer an endeavour. A decision qualifies by meeting at least 2 of 5 criteria, and the page sets out the 5 and what stays outside the test.
- The 7 properties of a governed decision What is written down before a decision goes live. The page defines each property and shows what the established methods for deciding leave out.
- The Kettei Card and the Watchcard The Kettei Card records the decision when it is made. The Watchcard governs it in flight, and each Watchcard is listed on the endeavour's Watchlist.
The properties
- The decision Owner One named person accountable for a decision's continuing validity. The page reads the British Army's Ajax programme, where the owner's box had a name in it throughout.
- Decision lifecycle states Proposed, Active, Suspended, Superseded, Revoked and Closed. The page sets out what each state means and the 3 ways a decision ends.
- Coupling, and the Novopay decisions What a decision depends on and what depends on it. The page reads the Ministerial Inquiry into Novopay, where the real go-live decision was made almost 3 months before go-live.
- Abort criteria The conditions, written in advance, under which a decision is revoked. The page separates the trigger from the abort and shows what a stopping rule written in advance does produce.
- Validity boundary The assumptions a decision stands on, the horizon for a forced review and the triggers that force an earlier one. The case is Peloton's Ohio factory.
Keeping watch
- Trigger register and watchkeeping How a decision is watched after approval inside a meeting the team already holds. The case is Equifax, where an inspection device ran for 19 months on an expired certificate.
- Point and call, act and call The railway practice of pointing and calling, and its reversal for a decision in flight. A declared value on the Watchcard is read aloud beside the observed one.
Failure modes
- The Kettei failure modes The ways a decision goes wrong after it is made, grouped by phase of the Ishi Spiral. This page is the hub for the failure-mode pages and links each mode to its case.
- Normalisation of deviance Deviations come to be treated as normal variation. The case is Challenger, read from the Rogers Commission and Diane Vaughan's study of the launch decision.
- Escalation of commitment Persistence on the strength of prior investment. The page sets out the experiments of Staw and of Simonson and Staw, and the London Stock Exchange's Taurus project.
- Governance theatre and watermelon reporting The appearance of governance with no monitoring of whether decisions remain valid. The case is Carillion, from the joint select committee report.
- Resulting Judging a decision by its result, in Annie Duke's borrowed poker word. The page shows how a governed review reads what was declared before it reads the outcome.
Where the research is
The sources behind these pages are gathered in the Research section, with the inquiry reports, regulator findings and published studies each page relies on. How Kettei relates to Ishi is set out on Ishi and Kettei, on ishi.co.nz.

Kettei
The Discipline of Governed Intent
