Case

Governance theatre and watermelon reporting

Governance theatre is the appearance of governance without monitoring of whether decisions remain valid. Watermelon reporting is its best-known sign, a status that is green on the outside and red on the inside.

In Kettei, governance theatre is a failure mode of the Reflect phase. Reports are filed and the dashboard stays green after progress toward the intent has stopped. Watermelon reporting need not involve anyone lying. Green is the one status that asks no action of anyone, so a programme manager under time pressure reports green for as long as the definition can be stretched.

By the time the status moves to amber the options have already narrowed. When it reaches red the executive team asks why it was not told sooner, though the reporting line told it what the line was built to tell. A line built to assure a board that a programme is within tolerance goes on doing so while the board believes it is receiving information.

The case

On 10 July 2017 Carillion, then the second largest construction company in the UK, announced a provision of £845 million against the value of its contracts. It went into liquidation on 15 January 2018 with liabilities of nearly £7 billion. In May 2018 a joint report of 2 House of Commons committees called the collapse "a story of recklessness, hubris and greed".

The machinery of oversight was in place. A board with 5 non-executive directors had an audit committee that reviewed papers on contract revenue quarterly, with an internal auditor and an external auditor. Site margins went through monthly project reviews and separate peer reviews meant to "provide challenge". Of the checks and balances the committees wrote that "These all failed".

Some of those controls saw the problem. In November 2016 a peer review of the Royal Liverpool University Hospital contract put it at a loss of 12.7%, and management recorded a profit margin of 4.9%. The chair of the audit committee, by his account, first heard of the variances in September 2017. On 1 March 2017 the accounts had been published with the auditor's unmodified opinion.

What Kettei asks

A contract margin recorded in the accounts is a decision, and in Kettei a decision has a single Owner and a validity boundary. Written that way, the hospital margin would name its assumption about final costs, with a trigger whose signal is a peer review that disagrees by more than a set amount.

The November 2016 review would have fired that trigger and sent the margin back to its Owner for revalidation within a fixed window, leaving a record of who kept 4.9% and on what evidence. Whether that would have changed Carillion's accounts is beyond what the record can settle.

The question to ask

A control earns its cost when what it finds can alter something someone has decided, and that link can be tested directly. Which of the organisation's controls has changed a decision in the last year?

Read the original

Watermelon Reporting was published on Kettei on Substack on 5 November 2026, and is gathered in Kettei Decision Digest 5: Failures of Stopping, Part 2. The essay also names 2 further records of a status reported as met, at Novopay and at Queensland Health's payroll.

Sources

  1. House of Commons Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy and Work and Pensions Committees (2018) Carillion. Second Joint report of Session 2017-19, HC 769, ordered printed 9 May 2018, published 16 May 2018. Establishes the provision, the liquidation, the peer review figures and the findings quoted above.

From the essay Watermelon Reporting on Kettei on Substack, 5 November 2026.

The cover of Kettei: The Discipline of Governed Intent by Gareth A Holebrook

Kettei

The Discipline of Governed Intent