Kettei term
Decision lifecycle states
A governed decision holds 1 of 6 lifecycle states, and it leaves Active by a recorded transition. The states are Proposed, Active, Suspended, Superseded, Revoked and Closed.
The established methods for deciding stop at the decision. Kettei gives a consequential decision a Lifecycle State, and a decision leaves Active by a recorded transition, with its rationale, to Suspended, Superseded, Revoked or Closed. Each change of state is recorded with a date, a name and the evidence.
The 6 states
- Proposed. The decision is formed and its 7 properties are declared on the Watchcard. A decision needs at least one abort criterion before it goes Active.
- Active. The decision governs the work, and the Owner holds its continuing validity. A change of tactic that keeps the strategy is recorded as an Adjust, and the decision stays Active.
- Suspended. The Owner judges that a validity boundary may have been breached. Irreversible steps stop while the decision is revalidated, and each dependent decision goes to mandatory revalidation.
- Superseded. A new decision replaces the old one and links back to it. A new validity boundary is a new decision, and a Suspended decision may move directly to Superseded.
- Revoked. The decision is ended. When an abort criterion is met the Owner declares the abort, and the decision moves from Active to Revoked with no need to pass through Suspended.
- Closed. A decision closes when it passes its point of no return with no abort left open. It no longer governs, and what follows belongs to new decisions.
How a decision ends
A Kettei decision ends in 1 of 3 ways. Its horizon concludes, where the verdict of the Reflect phase is Recommit, Pivot or Release. A breach of its validity boundary is confirmed on revalidation, and the decision is Revoked or Superseded. Or the Owner aborts it.
A Pivot is a change of strategy, so by definition it does not happen inside a live decision. It follows the end of one, and the new strategy is a new decision. Within a live decision the one change available is an Adjust, a change of tactic with the same strategy. If revalidation clears a Suspended decision, it returns to Active on its declared constraints.
The case
The government announced in September 2011 that the NHS National Programme for IT would be dismantled. In a report published in September 2013 the Public Accounts Committee found that "the component programmes are all continuing, the existing contracts are being honoured and significant costs are still being incurred."
The BT and CSC contracts "assumed a single end date". Each commitment therefore came up for decision again on an expiry date set when the contracts were let. The committee's record does not show that a shorter horizon would have bought a cheaper exit, because an exclusivity clause and the Department's own unmet obligation narrowed the options.
The question to ask
A commitment whose next reconsideration is an expiry date written into a contract has its validity tested on the contract's calendar, years after the conditions that justified it may have gone. On what date is this commitment next decided again, and who set that date?
Read the original
Nobody Wrote Down When to Stop was published on Kettei on Substack on 1 November 2026, and is gathered in Kettei Decision Digest 5: Failures of Stopping, Part 2. The comparison of methods is in 7 Systems Have a Decide. None Has a Lifecycle of 8 October 2026.
Sources
- House of Commons Committee of Public Accounts (2013) The dismantled National Programme for IT in the NHS. Nineteenth Report of Session 2013-14, HC 294, 18 September 2013. Establishes that the component programmes and contracts continued after the 2011 announcement, and that the contracts assumed a single end date.
From the essay Nobody Wrote Down When to Stop on Kettei on Substack, 1 November 2026.

Kettei
The Discipline of Governed Intent
