Research

The research behind the 7 properties

Each of the 7 properties answers a gap that a public record shows. This page gives one source for each property, what that source found, and what Kettei takes from it.

Kettei treats a consequential decision as an object with 7 properties, declared before the decision goes Active. The 7 are the Owner, reversibility, lifecycle state, coupling, scope, abort criteria and the validity boundary, and each is defined at The 7 properties of a governed decision.

The set of 7 is Kettei's own. Each source below establishes that one property was missing in one case, or that a single mechanism has an effect under test conditions. Those sources do not propose the 7 as a set, and do not show that declaring the 7 would have changed the outcome each records.

What the sources found, and how Kettei applies each

PropertyWhat the source foundHow Kettei applies it
OwnerThe Sheldon review (2023) called the senior responsible owner's role on Ajax "a single point of contact and accountability", and found the owner had to split the job with several other roles. The National Audit Office (2022) reported the owner "was initially allocated to the programme for 10% of his time".One named person is accountable for the decision's continuing validity. The role may not be shared, left vacant or held by a committee.
ReversibilityThe Public Accounts Committee (2013) recorded that ending one NHS supply contract might have meant paying the supplier the full value of the contract, because of an exclusive right to supply 160 trusts.Reversibility is set at creation and monitored, and is judged by the cost of changing the decision against the cost of delay. The hardest commitments to undo take the tightest horizons.
Lifecycle stateThe same committee found that after the programme was announced as dismantled, "the component programmes are all continuing, the existing contracts are being honoured and significant costs are still being incurred."A decision holds 1 of 6 states and leaves Active by a recorded transition, with a date, a name and the evidence.
CouplingThe Ministerial Inquiry into Novopay (2013) found that abandoning the phased rollout and the pilot "increased the project's dependency on testing", and that neither party fully appreciated the increased dependency.A decision declares at creation what it depends on and what depends on it. When it is Suspended, each dependent decision goes to mandatory revalidation.
ScopeAccording to the final report of the US House Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure (2020), a change during flight testing gave the 737 MAX's flight-control software more authority at low speed.Scope records what a decision covers, what it leaves out and what authority it delegates. A change to scope goes through a governed transition, recorded and dated with its reasons.
Abort criteriaThe Securities and Exchange Commission (2013) found that Knight Capital "did not have procedures in place to halt SMARS's operations in response to its own aberrant activity." Simonson and Staw (1992) found that targets written before results reduced over-commitment.Abort criteria are tuned to the decision's own stopping conditions and set before execution begins. The Owner, and only the Owner, declares the abort.
Validity boundaryThe Rogers Commission (1986) found that later reviews accepted recurring damage because it fell "within the data base" of earlier flights. Peloton's filings (2021, 2022) record a forecast cut months before the factory built on it was wound down.The boundary holds the principal assumptions, a horizon for a forced review and the triggers that force an earlier one. A confirmed breach ends the decision, and a new validity boundary is a new decision.

Where the 7 came from

The first week of the Kettei essays set out 4 cases, Boeing, Lion Air Flight 610, Silicon Valley Bank and Knight Capital. In each one a decision was made with care and went into execution, after which the programme and the budget each had an owner and the decision was left without one. At least one of the 7 properties was missing from each of the 4.

The essay that compares established methods reports that 2 of the properties did not appear together in what was read for it. Those are a validity boundary written when the decision is made, and a set of abort criteria with the authority to act on one. That finding is a statement about the sources read, and the essay words it that way.

Sources

  1. Sheldon, C. (2023) Report of the Armoured Cavalry Programme (Ajax) Lessons Learned Review. Ministry of Defence, 19 May 2023.
  2. National Audit Office (2022) The Ajax programme. Report by the Comptroller and Auditor General, HC 1142, Session 2021-22, 11 March 2022.
  3. House of Commons Committee of Public Accounts (2013) The dismantled National Programme for IT in the NHS. Nineteenth Report of Session 2013-14, HC 294, published 18 September 2013.
  4. Ministerial Inquiry into the Novopay Project (Jack, M. and Wevers, M.) (2013) Report of the Ministerial Inquiry into the Novopay Project. Wellington, June 2013.
  5. US House Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure (2020) Final Committee Report: The Design, Development and Certification of the Boeing 737 MAX. September 2020.
  6. US Securities and Exchange Commission (2013) In the Matter of Knight Capital Americas LLC. Release No. 34-70694, 16 October 2013.
  7. Simonson, I. and Staw, B. M. (1992) Deescalation strategies: A comparison of techniques for reducing commitment to losing courses of action. Journal of Applied Psychology 77(4), 419-426. DOI 10.1037/0021-9010.77.4.419.
  8. Presidential Commission on the Space Shuttle Challenger Accident (Rogers, W. P., Chairman) (1986) Report of the Presidential Commission on the Space Shuttle Challenger Accident, Volume 1.
  9. Peloton Interactive, Inc. (2021) Q1 2022 Shareholder Letter, 4 November 2021; and (2022) Peloton Announces Comprehensive Program to Reduce Costs and Drive Growth, Profitability, and Free Cash Flow, press release, 8 February 2022.

Read the originals

The 4 cases and the properties are gathered in Kettei 1: The Decision Nobody Governed of 8 October 2026. The table of properties is held as a one-page resource at The 7 properties, and the briefing for technology leaders is at Decision Ownership After the Rubber Stamp.

From the essay Kettei 1: The Decision Nobody Governed on Kettei on Substack, 8 October 2026.

The cover of Kettei: The Discipline of Governed Intent by Gareth A Holebrook

Kettei

The Discipline of Governed Intent